What’s Good For the Goose…
…must not be good for the gander.
I’m surprised this hasn’t been brought up prior to now.
I took the time to re-read the full speech published on U2.com Paul McGuinness gave to those at the MIDEM International Manager Summit.
In his remarks, Mr. McGuinness stated, “They have families and it is terrible that a direct effect of piracy and thievery has been the destruction of so many careers.” This was in regard to the losses of jobs in the record industry due to the loss of profits and the forced consolidation of the labels.
Wasn’t it Bono who said “Every artist is a cannibal, every poet is a thief?”
Readers of atu2 may remember reading a story written by Kevin Hutchinson back in July 2005 about Polish artist Piotr Mlodozeniec, the creator of the CoeXisT image in 2000 which Bono utilized in one of the most dramatic parts of the Vertigo Tour (which McGuinness shared that in 2005/2006 grossed $355m and played to 4.6m people in 26 countries.)
The CoeXisT image was created for an exhibition by The Museum on the Seam in Jerusalem. The Museum on the Seam’s Director and Curator, Raphie Etgar, said in a statement, “It is the responsibility of the Museum on the Seam to protect the images and the rights of the artists participating in the exhibition.”
When atu2 last communicated with Mr. Mlodozeniec, he received a credit on Vertigo 2005: Live from Chicago DVD but he did not state that he received any financial compensation for the use of his artwork. He went on to let us know, “the people from U2 proposed me long time ago to give them my sign as royality free (i haven’t done this). now they are not contacting me
anymore. if the museum on the seam had got something - i was not informed.” The Museum on the Seam has not updated us as to if they received any compensation.
If Mr. McGuinness feels that there are thieves in the midst, then he and/or U2 should revisit the use of this artist’s work as part of their live show which they made $335 million.
The kicker - I believe Mr. Mlodozeniec was remarkably missing from the credits at the conclusion of U2 3D. Shouldn’t he be compensated for the use of his image in this film as well?
The other kicker - in the United States, the CoeXisT image was trademarked by coexistonline.com. Piotr was unable to copyright his own image, nor was the Museum on the Seam able to protect him as an artist.

